1st Team
| QB | Nate Banick | Hurricanes |
| WR | Jeff Kotel | Penguins |
| WR | Nelson Ocasio | Outlawz |
| C | Kyle Makar |
Sofa King Good |
| S | Julian Hayes |
Hurricanes |
| CB | John Tul | Outlawz |
| CB | Bob Perez | Roth Bros. |
| R | Josh Pontius | NB Dynasty |
2nd Team
| QB | Jay Moore | Penguins |
| WR | Jeff Fowler | Hurricanes |
| WR | John Burd | Boak & Sons |
| C | Brandon Pavone | Hurricanes |
| S | Dane Stilgenbauer | Sofa King Good |
| CB | Brett Peruzzi | Hurricanes |
| CB | Steve McNeely | Boak & Sons |
| R | Nick Leiter | Roth Bros. |
